[This review was originally posted to the Jag-lovers XK Mailing list and is reproduced with John's permission.
John is co-author of the book 'The Jaguar XK in Australia']
A few of us have had the good fortune to have seen some of
Urs' book in proof form, and I recall some very favourable comments a couple
of months back from a Lister who had seen these in Paris.
I just want to say that, from the proofs, I believe Urs' book is
nothing short of magnificent!
He has deliberately chosen to stick with 120s at this stage due
to the huge job of covering the field of all XKs, and this has enabled him
to really get down to the fine detail. Looking through the proofs, it is
almost like he has taken every part of an XK (including detailed engine
parts) and photographed the different 120 versions of these side by
side for comparison purposes.
An example is the front timing chain cover, shown
in different versions front and back. All the blocks and heads are
there also and detailed changes to crankshafts. It is like a super parts
book with every detail photographically illustrated.
Another feature is the treatment of alloy 120s, where Urs owns
one or two very original examples, and they are shown partly dismantled.
A book like Phillip Porter's Original Jaguar XK is also a
magnificent achievement, but was written to the requirements of a
commercial publisher (limiting things like the final size, number and
size of photos etc) and therefore cannot hope to cover in the same depth as
Urs has done for the 120.
Also the Porter book is produced at what I would
regard as a very modest price (about GBP20) and is fantastic value.
It appears however that Urs' book is not constrained by commercial
considerations in any way and has been produced to satisfy an inner
urge to document all about 120s for the benefit and enjoyment of us all.
It is full of pictures, fully captioned, and with an attractive
up to date layout.
The text is in German but I understand that an English
edition is being worked on. I have a small German / English XK
dictionary produced with Rob Reilly a few years ago (a few pages of technical terms re
XKs) which I have sent to Urs and I think we will probably get it put up on
the XK-Lovers website for ready reference.
The pictures tell the story anyway.
So, have I said enough? If you have the slightest interest in
XKs, you should buy this book and marvel at it and get great pleasure from
it. If you have the slightest interest in motoring literature you should
also buy it. It is a classic already.
I don't know what the price will be but I expect it to be
expensive especially for US buyers who, in my opinion, looking from Australia,
have always been able to get books nearly for free!
Whatever, the cost will be but a fraction of the cost of production in terms of
the years of research etc that have gone into it.
[Addenda]
I have now received my copy of Urs' book Jaguar XK120.
I should now add that it is a magnificent production - everything about it is of the highest quality -
for example, the general layout and artwork, and the wonderful photography,
crystal clear - and not just of beautiful cars in fields, but the finest
details of virtually every part.
There is also evidence throughout of the most painstaking research, with
items included such as copies of contemporary advertisements by suppliers
(e.g. Champion spark plugs) and also of packaging used by Lucas and others
when supplying replacement parts, or for the Minor Replacement Outfit etc.
This book is quite magnificent, and I wonder whether anything comparable
has ever been produced anywhere in the world for any other make or model of
motor vehicle.
John Elmgreen, Australia
June 2000